Site icon Daily Sport

Nicholls should have come clean over Kauto Star

Champion trainer Paul Nicholls today defended criticism as to why he did not reveal that his stable star Kauto Star had taken a crashing fall in a schooling session, but the big question that remains unanswered is why he made a statement A DAY after the mishap saying that he was “delighted” with how the horse had gone under Ruby Walsh.

The Ditcheat handler wrote on his Betfair column last Saturday: “Ruby was here on Friday morning to school some of our big guns. He schooled Kauto Star, Big Buck’s, Al Ferof and Join Together to name but four and I was delighted with them all.”

Yet just 24 hours earlier the truth was that the Gold Cup bound public favourite, who has been better than ever this year and landed an unprecedented fifth win in the King George, had in fact taken – in the words of his handler – a “pretty awful fall”.

What makes matters worse that when Nicholls finally did make the mater public in a statement yesterday he said that his stables policy was to be “up front and honest” about the well being of its horses.

The statement said: “There is no easy way to say this, but Kauto Star is only 50-50 to make the Cheltenham Gold Cup after a fall schooling.

“As a trainer, it is all too easy to sit on information when it comes to your horses.

“They have so many minor worries, niggles and setbacks – most of which turn out to be nothing of long-term importance – that you could be constantly updating on each of your string, to the press and the public, on a hourly, daily and weekly basis.

“But our policy at Ditcheat is always to be up front and honest about the well-being of our horses – such as the coughing scare last week – and especially so when it is a public, and once-in-a-lifetime horse, such as Kauto.”

He added: “In my opinion, the public have a right to know. In many ways, he is as much theirs, as Clive Smith’s and ours.”

So given Kauto Star’s high profile surely Nicholls should have come clean last Saturday and said the horse had fallen badly, rather than saying he was “delighted” with how the schooling session had gone.

Yet it seems that the racing press, who are quick to criticise other trainers over providing/not providing information on their horses, are scared to question anything Nicholls says.

With the Cheltenham Festival now less than two weeks away, the clash between Kauto and Long Run is by far the most eagerly awaited for many a year and punters have placed huge sums on the outcome.

But this is not about punting, it’s about a trainer that claims to be “up front and honest” about his horses being just that.

Today Nicholls told At The Races why he had delayed a decision on making the news public until yesterday.

He said: “Clifford alerted to me that he felt on Wednesday morning, although he worked nicely, he just felt a little bit sore and, in his opinion, which is very important, it might be 50-50 that he could run at Cheltenham.

“Once Clifford had given me that information, I spoke to Clive, updated him and said ‘look I want to make a statement saying what happened’. I waited until yesterday afternoon because it was Josh Gifford’s memorial service and I didn’t want to say anything until after that and then I let everyone know the situation we were in.”

However what Nicholls has conveniently forgotten is that he did make a statement about the horse last Saturday, claiming that all was well.

That makes the handling of this whole affair very unsatisfactory in my eyes.

Kauto Star is no ordinary horse and has captured the nations hearts. He is the star attraction and has attracted thousands of new followers to the sport.

So surely the public deserve to be told the truth and kept informed from day one when his participation in what is the feature race of the Festival remains hanging in the balance.

 

Exit mobile version