Chelsea 2-3 Manchester United
Mata 44, Ramires 53 Luiz 4 (OG), Van Persie 12, Hernandez 75
Referee: M Clattenburg (Durham)
Chelsea (4-2-3-1): P Cech (captain); B Ivanovic, D Luiz, G Cahill, A Cole; Ramires, J Mikel; J Mata (R Bertrand, 72), Oscar (C Azpilicueta, 66, E Hazard (D Sturridge, 82); F Torres
Subs not used: R Turnbull, O Romeu, V Moses, M Marin
Manchester United (4-4-1-1): D De Gea; Rafael, R Ferdinand, J Evans, P Evra (captain); A Valencia, M Carrick, T Cleverley (J Hernandez, 65), A Young; W Rooney (R Giggs, 74); R Van Persie
Subs not used: A Lindegaard, Anderson, Nani, D Welbeck, P Scholes
Manchester United closed to within a point of Premier League leaders Chelsea after a dramatic win at Stamford Bridge in which the home side controversially had two men dismissed.
An own goal from Chelsea’s David Luiz and from Robin van Persie had given United a convincing-looking lead before goals from Juan Mata and Ramires brought the home side into a position from which it appeared they could win. Branislav Ivanovic and then – wrongly – Fernando Torres were sent off, and from that point United took advantage to produce Javier Hernandez’s winning goal and claim the three victorious points that had threatened to slip away.
The afternoon began with minimal controversy after Rio Ferdinand and Ashley Cole shook hands in the customary but unnecessary pre-match handshake but it would not stop the former’s touch being booed in front of the suspended John Terry, who sat in the dug out wearing a Kick It Out badge.
In his absence Gary Cahill had another opportunity to impress in the pursuit of a regular starting position but for him the afternoon did not begin well. After only two minutes United’s Van Persie had provided a reminder of his threat with a shot from 25 yards that Petr Cech comfortably saved but after only a further two it was he who had inspired the lead.
The forward struck a powerful shot against the post from inside the area with an effort that had this time defeated the goalkeeper but in bouncing back it hit the helpless Luiz to roll over the line and in.
The talented Dutchman may have felt as though his efforts were deserving of a goal but after a brief exchange in which his captain Patrice Evra appeared hurt following a hard but fair sliding challenge from Chelsea’s Branislav Ivanovic, another opportunity was to come his way and it was one that would not go to waste.
Leading a counter attack down the right, United winger Antonio Valencia sent in a low ball across the penalty box that should have been Cahill’s to clear but in slipping to the floor he presented the chance for Van Persie to capitalise with a classically lethal strike into the bottom left corner.
Before the match, United manager Sir Alex Ferguson had taunted Chelsea in saying that they were not as “ruthless” as Jose Mourinho’s all-conquering 2005 side and so it was apparently proving. After only 12 minutes United had taken a two-goal lead and with two banks of four in position to help maintain that lead, the home side’s task was looking increasingly difficult.
The first true signs of danger and of a comeback only came at the other end from the 24th minute but from that point onwards the home side demonstrated their impressive potency. The delightful floating Juan Mata, Oscar and Eden Hazard attempted to stretch United’s under strength back four to create an opportunity for the again sadly listless and frustrated figure of Fernando Torres but it was Luiz who first came closest to a goal.
A foul from Michael Carrick on Ramires gave the Brazilian a shooting opportunity from a free-kick from the edge of the box which he cleverly curled into the bottom left corner but which United goalkeeper David de Gea superbly instinctively saved with his feet.
It was an effort from which Chelsea took confidence and from then until the end of the half the pressure continued to build until the crucial breakthrough came. Another free-kick from the edge of the box after a foul on Hazard from Wayne Rooney presented Mata with a goalscoring opportunity whereupon he didn’t disappoint.
De Gea had since produced another sensational reactionary save but this was an effort to which even he was no match. The Spanish forward masterfully targeted the inside of the far left post with an inswinging free-kick that flew into the top corner with only two minutes of the half to go. From a vulnerable position Chelsea had received an obvious lift, and it meant that at half-time the match was far more open then it could possibly have been.
Chelsea’s pressure continued almost instantly after the re-start, and with only eight minutes of the second half played they created what could have been a decisive equaliser. Oscar’s curling ball towards Mata in the box and when the Spaniard returned the ball to the Brazilian who was now in the box, the latter chipped an inviting cross towards compatriot Ramires which he convincingly beat Tom Cleverley to to head his side level.
It was suddenly United who appeared under threat, particularly as Chelsea continued to convince, but the 63rd minute red card to Ivanovic thereafter completely changed the game. The defender could have little argument when as the last man he tripped the advancing Ashley Young as he attempted to find a way through on goal, and it became difficult to not foresee United capitalising.
If the common conception of Chelsea’s Roberto Di Matteo is that he is in reality a lucky manager, Torres’ sending off which soon followed would not be considered an incident that would strengthen such an argument. The Chelsea striker had already picked up what had appeared an innocuous booking on the stroke of half-time before, in the 63rd minute, he was tripped by Johnny Evans when trying to force a way through on goal and was wrongly booked again and consequently dismissed for what referee Mark Clattenburg thought was a dive.
From the enviable position of possessing the match’s momentum, the home side were suddenly down to nine men. The obvious lack of justice in this sparked uncharacteristic anger and emotion from Di Matteo, who exchanged heated words with Ferguson on the touchline as he came to the realisation that his impressive side was now heading to a likely defeat.
For his part, Ferguson sought to capitalise on the two-man numerical advantage and introduced the clinical Javier Hernandez to target the winner as Rooney was removed to eliminate the potential of a dismissal for himself.
United suddenly had considerably greater space for them to counter with and over 20 minutes for it to produce the decisive goal, yet the in-form Hernandez needed only five.
Another cross had been sent into the box when Rafael shot goalwards and the striker turned it in with another display of his natural predatory skills. 15 minutes remained with United in front and with such space there could have been more, but they professional and cleverly maintained their lead to secure a vital victory that keeps them only a solitary point from the top.

